Subdomain vs. Subdirectory vs. ccTLD for SEO

published on 16 May 2024

Choosing the right URL structure for your multilingual website can make or break your SEO. Here's what you need to know:

  • Subdirectories (example.com/uk/): Best for most businesses. Share domain authority, easy to manage.
  • Subdomains (uk.example.com): Treated as separate sites by Google. Can dilute SEO efforts.
  • ccTLDs (example.co.uk): Strong for local SEO, but expensive and complex to manage.

Quick Comparison:

Feature Subdirectory Subdomain ccTLD
SEO Impact Strong Moderate Strong (locally)
Setup Easy Moderate Complex
Cost Low Medium High
Local Trust Good OK Best

For most businesses, subdirectories are the way to go. They're SEO-friendly, cost-effective, and easier to manage. But if you're targeting specific countries and have the resources, ccTLDs can give you a local edge.

No matter what you choose, use hreflang tags and create unique, valuable content for each market.

Key Concepts

Let's break down the three main URL structures for multilingual SEO: subdomains, subdirectories, and ccTLDs.

Subdomains

A subdomain is like a mini-website within your main site. It comes before your domain name.

Example: cars.disney.com

Google treats subdomains as separate websites. They're crawled and indexed on their own.

Subdirectories

A subdirectory is a folder within your main domain. It comes after your domain name.

Example: victorious.com/blog/

Google sees subdirectories as part of your main domain. This means link equity benefits all content under that domain.

ccTLDs

A ccTLD is a domain extension for a specific country or territory.

Example: .fr for France

ccTLDs are great for ranking in specific countries. Google assumes all content on a ccTLD is for that country.

URL Structure Example SEO Impact
Subdomain blog.example.com Separate site
Subdirectory example.com/blog Part of main domain
ccTLD example.fr Strong country signal

When choosing, think about your audience and SEO goals. Subdirectories work well for most sites. ccTLDs are great for targeting specific countries.

"Google web search is fine with using either subdomains or subdirectories." - John Mueller, Google

Subdomains in Detail

Subdomains are mini-websites within your main site. They appear before your domain name, like blog.example.com.

How Subdomains Function

Subdomains create a separate section of your website with its own URL. When you type a subdomain URL, the Domain Name System (DNS) finds the right website.

Disney uses subdomains for different properties:

  • parks.disney.com (theme parks)
  • video.disney.com (streaming content)
  • shop.disney.com (online shopping)

Each subdomain can point to a different server, making it easier to manage big websites.

Subdomain Pros and Cons

Pros Cons
Organize content Google treats them as separate sites
Test new features May weaken domain authority
Create brand experiences More sites to maintain
Add keywords to URL Separate link-building needed

Google's John Mueller says:

"From an indexing and ranking perspective, Google doesn't have a preference."

But many SEOs think subdomains don't rank as well because they're seen as separate entities.

To make subdomains work for SEO:

  1. Use clear, keyword-rich names
  2. Link between main domain and subdomains
  3. Submit each subdomain to Google Search Console
  4. Build backlinks for each subdomain

Subdirectories in Detail

Subdirectories are folders within your main domain that organize website content. They show up after the domain name in the URL (example.com/blog).

How Subdirectories Work

Subdirectories are part of your main website. No special setup needed - just create them in your content management system.

For multilingual sites, you might use:

  • example.com/en (English)
  • example.com/es (Spanish)
  • example.com/fr (French)

This keeps everything under one domain. Easy to manage.

Subdirectory Pros and Cons

Pros Cons
Share domain authority Possible URL confusion
Easy setup Less design flexibility
Simple content management Same server, might load slower
Clear structure Harder to separate traffic data

John Mueller from Google says:

"From an indexing and ranking perspective, Google doesn't have a preference."

But many SEO pros think subdirectories have an edge. Why? They're clearly part of the main domain.

To use subdirectories well:

  1. Use clear names (/blog, /products)
  2. Keep URLs simple and logical
  3. Link between subdirectories and main pages
  4. Use hreflang tags for different languages

ccTLDs in Detail

Country Code Top-Level Domains (ccTLDs) are domain extensions for specific countries or territories. They're a key tool for targeting users in particular regions.

How ccTLDs Function

ccTLDs use a two-letter code for each country:

  • .uk for the United Kingdom
  • .de for Germany
  • .fr for France

Using a ccTLD is like putting up a big sign that says, "This website is for people in [country]!" Google sees it as a strong signal. If you have a .de domain, Google assumes your content is for German users.

ccTLD Pros and Cons

Pros Cons
Strong geo-targeting Separate domains per country
Boosts local rankings More expensive
Builds local trust Harder to manage
Clear country focus May limit global reach

ccTLDs are great for focusing on one country, but they can make going global trickier.

Take Amazon, for example. They use different ccTLDs for each country:

  • amazon.co.uk for the UK
  • amazon.fr for France
  • amazon.de for Germany

This helps them tailor content and products to each market. But it also means managing multiple websites.

PayPal, on the other hand, uses a global domain with country-specific subfolders:

  • paypal.com/mx for Mexico
  • paypal.com/es for Spain
  • paypal.com/fr for France

It's easier to manage but might not have as strong a local signal as ccTLDs.

When choosing ccTLDs, think about your resources and goals. If you're all-in on one country and can handle a separate site, go for it. But if you're aiming global or have limited resources, look at other options.

Here's a key point: ccTLDs target countries, not languages. A .es domain (for Spain) won't help you reach Spanish speakers in Mexico or Argentina.

One last thing: some ccTLDs have strict rules. For a .ca domain, you need to be Canadian or have a physical presence in Canada. Always check the requirements before diving in.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Let's compare subdomains, subdirectories, and ccTLDs:

Feature Subdomain Subdirectory ccTLD
URL Structure uk.example.com example.com/uk example.co.uk
SEO Signal Strength Weak Medium Strong
Domain Authority Separate Inherits Separate per country
Setup Complexity Moderate Easy Complex
Maintenance More effort Easier Most demanding
Cost Moderate Lowest Highest
User Trust Moderate High Highest locally
Google's View Separate site Part of main site Country-specific site

Examples:

Subdomains: Not great for SEO. A financial company switched from .com to subdomain, lost traffic. Switching back? 15% traffic boost.

Subdirectories: Apple, Samsung, HP use these for international sites. Cost-effective and SEO-friendly.

ccTLDs: Amazon uses different ones per country (amazon.co.uk, amazon.fr, amazon.de). Good for targeting, but managing multiple sites is tough.

Expert take:

"Choosing between ccTLD, subdomain, and subdirectory? Go with subdirectory. Almost always."

But it's not one-size-fits-all. PayPal uses a global domain with country subfolders (paypal.com/mx, paypal.com/es, paypal.com/fr). Global presence meets local targeting.

Key points:

  • Google sees subdomains as separate sites
  • Subdirectories get SEO juice from main domain
  • ccTLDs? Strongest country signals, but resource-heavy

Choosing your structure? Think about your audience, resources, and long-term international SEO plan. It can make or break your global online game.

Effects on Search Rankings

Your URL structure choice can make or break your search rankings. Here's how each option stacks up:

Subdomains

Subdomains often struggle in search rankings:

  • Google sees them as separate sites
  • They don't fully tap into the main domain's link juice
  • Watch out for duplicate content issues

Subdirectories

Subdirectories usually win the SEO game:

  • They're part of the main domain, sharing its authority
  • Link equity flows throughout the domain
  • Easier to manage under one roof

ccTLDs

Country Code Top-Level Domains (ccTLDs) are a mixed bag:

  • They get a local search boost
  • Users tend to trust them more

Let's break it down:

Feature Subdomains Subdirectories ccTLDs
SEO Authority Separate Shared Country-specific
Local Ranking Weak Moderate Strong
Link Equity Limited Shared Isolated
User Trust Moderate High Highest (locally)

"Generally speaking the local domain names, in your case .kr, tend to do better because Google Search promotes content local to the user." - Gary Illyes, Google

This shows why ccTLDs can be a smart move for targeting specific countries.

Moz, the SEO big shots, moved their content from a subdomain to a subfolder. The result? Their search rankings shot up. It's more proof that subdirectories often outperform subdomains in SEO.

So, what's the bottom line?

  1. Subdirectories often give you the best SEO bang for your buck
  2. ccTLDs can boost local rankings, but you'll need separate SEO efforts for each country
  3. Subdomains might struggle to keep up with subdirectories in the rankings race

When picking your URL structure, think about who you're trying to reach, what resources you have, and your long-term SEO game plan. Choose wisely, and you could see a big jump in your search visibility and online success.

User Experience Factors

Your site structure affects how users interact with your content. Let's break down how subdomains, subdirectories, and ccTLDs impact user experience.

Subdomains

Subdomains create separate spaces for different parts of your site. Semrush uses this for language versions:

  • es.semrush.com (Spanish)
  • fr.semrush.com (French)

Pros:

  • Tailored content for each section
  • Feels like distinct websites

Cons:

  • Can fragment user experience

Subdirectories

Subdirectories keep everything under one roof. The American Lung Association uses this approach.

Pros:

  • Easy navigation
  • Consistent branding
  • Simpler management

ccTLDs

Country Code Top-Level Domains (ccTLDs) focus on local appeal.

Pros:

  • Build local trust
  • Show geographic relevance
  • Allow country-specific content

Quick comparison:

Feature Subdomains Subdirectories ccTLDs
User Trust OK Good Best (locally)
Navigation Can be tricky Usually easy Easy within country
Localization Good Good Best
Branding Separate Unified Country-specific

Focus on what works best for your users.

An example: VIOS Fertility saw a 128% increase in new organic users after switching to subdirectories.

For international businesses, ccTLDs can be powerful. They're 1.5 times more likely to be trusted by local users.

When choosing your structure, consider:

  1. Where your target audience is
  2. How much you want to localize
  3. Your resources for managing multiple sites or sections
sbb-itb-b8bc310

Setup and Maintenance

Let's break down how to set up and maintain your website structure for SEO. We'll look at subdirectories, subdomains, and ccTLDs.

Subdirectories: Easy as Pie

Subdirectories are just folders on your site. They're simple to set up and maintain.

Why they're great:

  • Quick to set up
  • Cheap to maintain
  • Easy to track in Google tools

Real-world example: Nike uses subdirectories for different countries:

  • nike.com/ca (Canada)
  • nike.com/ca/fr (French Canada)
  • nike.com/fr (France)

This keeps everything under one roof. Smart move, Nike!

Subdomains: The Standalone Siblings

Subdomains need more work. Google often sees them as separate sites.

The good:

  • Can live on different servers
  • Allow different content strategies

The not-so-good:

  • Need their own SEO work
  • Might create duplicate content issues

True story: A finance company moved to a subdomain and lost traffic. When they switched back to the main domain, traffic jumped 15%. Lesson learned!

ccTLDs: The Local Heroes

Country Code Top-Level Domains (ccTLDs) are the trickiest to set up.

The upside:

  • Show you're local
  • Build trust with local users

The downside:

  • Expensive to set up and run
  • Need separate SEO for each domain

Tip: If you're going global, try this:

  • example.com (US)
  • example.co.uk (Europe)
  • example.jp (Asia)

Quick Comparison

Feature Subdirectories Subdomains ccTLDs
Setup Difficulty Easy Medium Hard
Upkeep Cost Low Medium High
SEO Work All together Separate Separate
Servers Needed One Can be many Many
Content Control Central Can be spread out Spread out

For most businesses, subdirectories are the sweet spot. But your choice should match your goals and resources.

Cost and Branding

Choosing between subdomains, subdirectories, and ccTLDs? It's all about money and brand image. Here's the lowdown:

Subdirectories: Cheap and Consistent

Subdirectories won't break the bank. They're just folders on your main site. No extra costs, and your brand stays the same everywhere.

Cost: $ (Lowest) Brand Consistency: High

Subdomains: The Middle Path

Subdomains cost more than subdirectories, less than ccTLDs. You might need separate hosting. They're linked to your main domain but feel a bit different.

Cost: $$ (Medium) Brand Consistency: Medium

ccTLDs: Expensive but Local

ccTLDs hit your wallet hard. You're buying new domains for each country. Plus, separate hosting and SSL certificates for each.

Cost: $$$ (Highest) Brand Consistency: Low

Here's a quick comparison:

Feature Subdirectories Subdomains ccTLDs
Domain Cost $0 $0-$20/year $10-$100+/year per country
Hosting Shared Maybe separate Separate
SSL Certificates Shared Maybe separate Separate
SEO Effort One Separate Separate

Nike's Smart Move

Nike

Nike uses subdirectories for different countries:

  • nike.com/ca (Canada)
  • nike.com/fr (France)

It's cheap and keeps their brand consistent globally. Smart!

Brand Talk

  1. Subdirectories: Your main brand stays front and center.
  2. Subdomains: Slightly separate feel, but still connected.
  3. ccTLDs: Great for local vibes, but can split your global image.

Save Some Cash

  1. On a tight budget? Start with subdirectories.
  2. Use translation software. It's cheaper than hiring translators.
  3. If you need ccTLDs, start with your key markets first.

Google's Stance

Google's view on subdomains, subdirectories, and ccTLDs for SEO has changed. Here's what you need to know:

Subdomains vs. Subdirectories

Google treats these the same for SEO. John Mueller from Google said:

"From our point of view, when we talk with the search quality team, they say subdomains and subdirectories are essentially equivalent. You can put your content however you want."

But watch out: Google might sometimes see a subdomain as a separate site.

ccTLDs and Geotargeting

ccTLDs can help with geotargeting. John Mueller explained:

"While a country code domain name helps our systems to geotarget for that country, it still allows for global visibility."

URL Structure Tips

For multilingual sites:

  1. Use unique URLs for each language
  2. Don't use URL parameters for geotargeting
  3. Use hreflang tags to show language versions

Local SEO Edge

Gary Illyes from Google noted:

"Generally speaking the local domain names, in your case .kr tend to do better because Google Search promotes content local to the user."

Quick Summary

What Google Says
Subdomains vs. Subdirectories Equal treatment
ccTLDs Good for geotargeting, not required
URL Structure Unique URLs per language
Local SEO ccTLDs have a small advantage

Examples

Let's see how big companies handle their international SEO with different URL structures:

Subdomains: CNN and Hotels.com

CNN

CNN uses subdomains for different languages:

  • edition.cnn.com (US/International)
  • arabic.cnn.com (Arabic)
  • espanol.cnn.com (Spanish)

This lets CNN keep separate content for each language under the main CNN.com domain.

Hotels.com does the same:

  • www.hotels.com (US/International)
  • uk.hotels.com (UK)
  • jp.hotels.com (Japan)

Subdirectories: BeatsByDre and Imperva Incapsula

BeatsByDre goes for subdirectories:

  • www.beatsbydre.com/us (US)
  • www.beatsbydre.com/uk (UK)
  • www.beatsbydre.com/fr (France)

This helps keep their domain authority strong across all versions.

Imperva Incapsula follows suit:

  • www.imperva.com/products/ddos-protection-services (US/International)
  • www.imperva.com/de/products/ddos-protection-services (German)

ccTLDs: McDonald's and Apple

McDonald's uses ccTLDs to target specific regions:

  • www.mcdonalds.com (US)
  • www.mcdonalds.co.uk (UK)
  • www.mcdonalds.fr (France)

This helps them tailor their online presence to local tastes, just like their menu variations.

Apple mixes it up:

  • www.apple.com (US/International)
  • www.apple.fr (France)
  • www.apple.com/uk (UK - subdirectory)

They use ccTLDs in strong markets and subdirectories in others, balancing regional targeting with domain authority.

Impact on SEO and User Experience

Company Strategy SEO Impact User Experience
CNN Subdomains Separate content management, possible SEO dilution Clear language separation
Hotels.com Subdomains Region-specific ranking, shared domain authority Easy regional navigation
BeatsByDre Subdirectories Unified domain authority, easier management Consistent global branding
McDonald's ccTLDs Strong regional targeting, separate link building High local relevance
Apple Mixed Flexible approach, balances authority and targeting Adapts to market strength

These examples show that choosing between subdomains, subdirectories, and ccTLDs depends on brand strength, target markets, and SEO goals. Companies often tweak their strategies based on their specific needs and market conditions.

How to Choose

Picking the right URL structure for multilingual SEO isn't easy. Here's how to make a smart choice:

Look at Your Goals and Resources

1. Who Are You Targeting?

Are you after specific countries or languages? If it's countries, ccTLDs might be your best bet. For languages, subdomains or subdirectories could work well.

2. What Can You Handle?

Think about your budget and tech skills:

URL Structure Cost Upkeep
ccTLD High Tough
Subdomain Medium OK
Subdirectory Low Easy

3. What's Your Brand Plan?

Big global companies often use ccTLDs to look local. Smaller businesses might stick with subdirectories for a unified brand.

Think About SEO

Google says they treat subdomains and subdirectories the same. But many SEO pros like subdirectories better. Why?

  • They share the main domain's authority
  • Link juice flows better within the site

Jesse Heap from Janssen saw 40% more traffic after moving a blog from a subdomain to a subdirectory.

Consider User Experience

How will your URL structure affect users?

  • ccTLDs: Look local, build trust
  • Subdomains: Easy to remember
  • Subdirectories: Simple to navigate

Check Out Real Examples

See how big names do it:

  • ccTLDs: McDonald's (mcdonalds.fr, mcdonalds.co.uk)
  • Subdomains: CNN (arabic.cnn.com, espanol.cnn.com)
  • Subdirectories: Apple (apple.com/uk, apple.com/fr)

Make Your Call

Based on all this, pick what works best for you. You can always change later if needed. Some companies, like Apple, mix it up to balance local targeting with domain power.

Still not sure? Start with subdirectories. They're cheap, easy to manage, and work well for most multilingual SEO plans.

Conclusion

Picking between subdomains, subdirectories, and ccTLDs for multilingual SEO isn't easy. But here's the deal: subdirectories often come out on top for most businesses.

Why? Simple:

  • They piggyback on your main domain's authority
  • They're cheaper and easier to handle
  • They keep your brand consistent

Don't just take my word for it. Jesse Heap from Janssen saw a 40% traffic boost after moving a blog to a subdirectory.

But let's break it down:

Option Good For Not So Good For
Subdirectories Most businesses Super country-specific targeting
Subdomains Big orgs with separate market brands Full main domain authority boost
ccTLDs Multinationals targeting specific countries Budget and separate SEO efforts

Still on the fence? Start with subdirectories. They're flexible, SEO-friendly, and good enough for Apple, Samsung, and HP.

Pro tip: Use common ISO codes for your subdirectories. "UK" for the United Kingdom, "ES" for Spanish content. Google loves that stuff.

No matter what you pick, use hreflang tags. They'll keep duplicate content issues at bay and tell search engines exactly who you're targeting.

Common Questions

Let's tackle some FAQs about subdomains, subdirectories, and ccTLDs for SEO:

Q: Which option is best for SEO?

There's no one-size-fits-all answer, but subdirectories often win. Why?

  • They piggyback on the main domain's authority
  • Google sees them as part of the main site
  • They're easier to manage and cheaper

John Mueller from Google says: "Google Web Search is fine with using either subdomains or subdirectories…use what works best for your setup and think about your longer-term plans when picking one or the other."

Q: How do subdomains affect SEO?

Google treats subdomains as separate websites. This means:

  • Separate crawling and indexing
  • No automatic authority boost from the main domain
  • Each subdomain needs its own SEO work

Q: Are ccTLDs good for local SEO?

Yep, ccTLDs can give local SEO a boost. Gary Illyes from Google explains: "Generally speaking the local domain names, in your case .kr tend to do better because Google Search promotes content local to the user."

Option Local SEO Impact Example
ccTLD Strong example.kr for Korea
Subdomain Moderate kr.example.com
Subdirectory Moderate example.com/kr

Q: How do URL structures impact SEO?

URL structure is a big deal for SEO. Remember:

  • Use relevant keywords in URLs
  • Keep URLs logical and easy to read
  • Avoid duplicate content issues

Paul Martin, Senior SEO Analyst at Epiphany Solutions, says: "One of the most overlooked issues of on-page optimisation by clients, and even many SEO agencies are guilty of this on occasion, is a website's URL structure."

Q: What about using subdomains for different products or services?

It's possible, but not usually the best for SEO. Try subdirectories instead:

  • Skip: products.example.com/product1
  • Use: example.com/products/product1

This approach builds domain authority and boosts overall site performance.

FAQs

Is a subdomain or subdirectory better for SEO?

Subdirectories usually win for SEO. Here's why:

  • Google sees subdomains as separate sites, which can split your SEO juice
  • Subdirectories share your main domain's SEO power
  • They're easier to manage

But most SEO pros prefer subdirectories for their SEO edge.

What's the difference between subdomain and ccTLD?

Feature Subdomain ccTLD
Structure part.example.com example.co.uk
SEO Impact So-so Great for local SEO
Setup Easy Trickier
Cost Cheaper Pricier
Trust Linked to main domain Builds local cred

ccTLDs can boost local SEO and trust, but they cost more and are harder to set up. Subdomains are easier to handle but might not shine as bright in local search.

What are the downsides of subdomains?

1. SEO hiccups: They might not get the full SEO boost from your main domain.

2. Tech headaches: Each subdomain needs its own hosting and upkeep.

3. User mix-ups: People might not realize subdomains are part of your main site.

4. Link building blues: You'll need separate link campaigns for each subdomain.

Austin Lewis from HawkSEM puts it this way:

"Typically, blog content should support pillar content with internal links to boost the topical authority and visibility of the pillar pages. And that doesn't work when your blogs are on a separate site."

When choosing between subdomains and subdirectories, think about what you need, what you can handle, and what your SEO goals are.

Related posts

Read more

Built on Unicorn Platform